← Blog Treatment Selection Guide Case Studies

Permanent vs temporary pothole repairs: what changes on the ground

Decision support Published: 2 Feb 2026
This supports the decision framework in our Treatment Selection Guide.

The difference isn’t just the material — it’s the outcome on a live network.

What changes first

  • Repeat visits drop: fewer callouts to the same location.
  • Closures reduce: fewer traffic management setups.
  • Disruption falls: less downtime for road users and clients.
  • True cost improves: lifecycle cost usually beats “cheap first visit”.

Use defect type, loading and environment to pick the right approach first time, rather than defaulting to the fastest patch.